With Halloween SO close (it’s NEXT week, you guys!), I’ve been getting SO many questions from you- you’re asking: are there ANY healthy Halloween candy options?! Which Halloween candy is the healthiest? Are there any healthy candy brands? (Then, “PLEASE say yes!” 😉 )
So let’s be real for a moment.
Nothing on my list below would I consider truly “healthy.” And I want to be clear about that. What I’m proposing instead, are healthy candy alternatives. Or should I say healthier candy alternatives.
Candy is going to have sugar in it. And we all know it’s pretty universally agreed upon that sugar’s not going to make you a healthier person.
BUT my goal with this blog post is to bring you candy that is healthier than what you would normally have on Halloween. Healthier than the standard Halloween candy.
The purpose of this post is also to give you options for healthy halloween candy options to PASS OUT. For that reason, this isn’t just a list of healthy halloween candy that you could eat at any time of the year. It’s mainly focused on packs and individualized boxes of healthy Halloween candy so you can pass it out or have it on your doorstep in a bowl.
Anything that comes in a bag with 50 gummy worms not individually wrapped didn’t make the cut. Also, anything that was exorbitantly expensive didn’t make the cut. I’m not going to be spending two dollars per kid who Trick-or-Treats at my house, and my guess is you aren’t either.
One of my favorite ways to get healthy Halloween candy is on Thrive Market! It’s shelf-stable healthy groceries, at great prices, delivered to your door. I’m obsessed! If you’ve never joined Thrive, you can today and get 20% off your first 3 orders!! Click the image below!
And if you want to know my list of the healthiest chocolate for Halloween or healthiest gummy candy for Halloween, scroll all the way to the bottom!
And be sure to check out my Instagram to win some of my favorites from my list! You can comment on this blog post for TEN extra entries- tell me: what’s your favorite healthy Halloween candy? I can’t wait to hear! Good luck!
List of Healthy Halloween Candy Options:
Surf Sweets Organic Spooky Shape Treat Pack
Surf Sweets Organic Spooky Shape Treat Pack20 pouches for $5.99 at Thrive Market
$0.30 per pouch!
Features: Organic, Vegan, No HFCS, Free of the Top 10 Common Allergens
Wholesome Ghost & Skull Lollipops
30 lollipops for $3.99 (20% off!) at Thrive Market
$0.13 per lollipop!
Features: Organic, Project Non-GMO Verified, Vegan, No HFCS, No Artificial Flavors, Free of the Top 10 Common Allergens, Made with Fair Trade Organic Cane Sugar, Certified Gluten Free, Nut Free, Vegan and Kosher.
Surf Sweets Organic Jelly Beans
60 packs for $31.81 on Amazon
$0.53 per pack!
Features: Organic, Project Non-GMO Verified, Vegetarian, No HFCS, No Artificial Flavors, Free of the Top 10 Common Allergens, Made with Fair Trade Organic Cane Sugar, Certified Gluten Free, and Nut Free.
YumEarth Family Size Snack Pack Gummy Bears
10 packs for $5.49 (23% off) on Thrive Market
$0.55 per pack!
Features: Non-GMO, Vegetarian, No HFCS, No Artificial Flavors, Free of the Top 10 Common Allergens, Made with Gluten Free, Nut Free, and Dairy Free.
Want 50 Packs?
YumEarth Naturals Gummy Bears, 50 Pack
50 packs for $23.09 (5% off) on Amazon
$0.46 per pack!
Features: Non-GMO, Vegetarian, No HFCS, No Artificial Flavors, Free of the Top 10 Common Allergens, Made with Gluten Free, Nut Free, and Dairy Free.
YumEarth Organic Sour Twists
10 packs for $5.49 (21% off) on Thrive Market
$0.55 per pack!
Features: Certified Organic, Non-GMO, Certified Vegan, No HFCS, No Artificial Flavors, Free of the Top 10 Common Allergens, Gluten Free, Nut Free, and Dairy Free.
YumEarth Organic Fruit Snacks
10 packs for $5.49 (21% off) on Thrive Market
$0.55 per pack!
Features: Certified Organic, Non-GMO, Certified Vegan, No HFCS, No Artificial Flavors, Free of the Top 10 Common Allergens, Certified Gluten Free, Nut Free, and Dairy Free.
YumEarth Organic Sour Beans
50 packs for $22.72 (5% off) on Amazon
$0.45 per pack!
Features: Certified Organic, Non-GMO, Certified Vegan, No HFCS, No Artificial Flavors, Free of the Top 10 Common Allergens, Certified Gluten Free, Nut Free, and Dairy Free.
Justin’s Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
OR
Justin’s Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
About 10 pieces for $4.99 (17% off!) on Thrive Market
$0.50 per piece!
Features: Certified Organic, Non-GMO, Vegan, No HFCS, No Artificial Flavors, Certified Gluten Free, high in protein, and low-FODMAP.
Unreal Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
40 pieces for $35.40 on Amazon
$0.89 per piece
Features: Verified Non-GMO, Non-GMO, Made with Fair Trade Certified, Responsibly-Sourced Ingredients
Unreal Milk Chocolate Gems
Guys these are like healthier M&M’s!!!
20 packs for $9.99 on Amazon
$0.50 per piece!
Features: Verified Non-GMO, Nothing Artificial, Made with Fair Trade Certified, Responsibly-Sourced Ingredients, colored with veggies
Enjoy Life Halloween Chocolate Candy Minis Variety Pack
72 pieces for $26.99 on Amazon
$0.37 per piece!
Features: Verified Non-GMO, Allergy-Friendly, Certified Gluten-Free, Kosher, Halal, free from gluten and wheat, peanuts, dairy, tree nuts, soy, casein, sulfites, egg, lupin, sesame, fish, mustard, crustaceans, shellfish.
Black Forest Organic Halloween Candy
Black Forest Organic Sourheads
24 Packs for $14.99 on Amazon
$0.62 / pack
Black Forest Organic Trick or Treat Candy Mix
60 Pieces from $23.92 on Amazon
$0.40 / piece
Features: Certified Organic, Natural colors and flavors.
Cocomels Coconut Milk Caramels- Variety Pack
About 60 pieces for $19.49 on Amazon
$0.32 per piece!
Features: Non-GMO, Organic, Kosher, Vegan, no High Fructose Corn Syrup, Dairy, Gluten or Soy.
OCHO Organics Halloween Variety Pack
132 pieces for $50 on their website
$0.38 per piece!
Features: Non-GMO, Organic, Gluten Free.
*They also have minis on their website that would be perfect for halloween!
Smart Sweet Gummies
30 packs for $17.98 on their website
$0.60 per pack!
Features: Gluten Free, Non-GMO, Dairy, Soy & Lactose Free, Free from Sugar Alcohols, Peanut + Tree Nut Free, Free from artificial colors.
Shop both Halloween options here.
If you’re looking for healthiest candies by category, look here!
What is the healthiest chocolate for Halloween?
- Justin’s Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
- Justin’s Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
- Unreal Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
- Enjoy Life Halloween Chocolate Candy Minis Variety Pack
- Unreal Milk Chocolate Gems
Healthiest Gummy Candy for Halloween
- Black Forest Organic Sourheads
- Surf Sweets Organic Spooky Shape Treat Pack
- YumEarth Organic Sour Twists
- YumEarth Naturals Gummy Bears
- Smart Sweet Gummies
Smart sweets are my favorite!
Really nice to find dairy free options on the list as unfortunately I cannot have dairy due to newly developed allergy.
We love the Smart Sweet gummies!!
Love it.yummy cansy
Some really great alternatives to traditional halloween candy! Thanks for the list
Can’t wait to try!!
I have been dying to try the Smart Sweets bears!
My favorite is anything black Forest. It is affordable but didn’t have unnatural food coloring
Oh it’s so nice to see healthier treat options! And very affordable!
Justin’s Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups are my all time favorite. Such a treat!!
Woo hoo so excited that you’re doing this giveaway!! So many yummy new things to try!
So many options gotta check them all out
The Justin PB cups are life savers when you just need a little chocolate to keep going!
So many options cant wait to check them out
Those milk chocolate peanut butter cups sound good right about now.
These are good choices for Halloween candy to pass out to trick-or-treaters but I would keep the Justin’s Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups for myself.
Mmm I love Justin’s dark chocolate PB cups! And I love there are so many options out there for healthier Halloween!
Healthy but just as yummy! Thanks for putting this list together!
So many good options, and I love how they are individually packaged! Portion control!
You spent some time on this. Thank you. A tasty endeavor. I have longed to try Thrive…just not in our budget for the membership. Exciting.
All my favorites! And some I didn’t know about!
Lots of options here! I wish everyone would go with quality over quantity! I tried the sweetsmarts gummy bears! I can taste the stevia but they are a good option if you’re trying to illuminate cane sugar.
That is a yummy group of snacks that has my little heart skippin’ beats! In my opinion, peanut butter and chocolate is the greatest flavor combination known to man…Unreal Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups top my list!
I had no idea Enjoy Life made products other than their baking chips! Thanks for this round up!
I love smart sweet gummies and choczero chocolate squares do son some healthy candy options! These options look great too!
awesome – thank you for the list – so many good things – love them all
I am loving some of these healthy treats. It would be great for the kids.
What a great list I’m always looking for healthy alternative snacks
Love the healthy candy options!!! Thanks! Austinmama1 on Instagram
We’ve followed the Feingold diet for 4 years. They research foods to ensure they don’t have artificial color, artificial flavor, and petrochemical preservatives. They also provide info on whether foods are gluten or casein free or if they have corn sweeteners or annatto, plus much more. Many of these treats are on the Feingold list!! http://www.feingold.org for more info
Thanks for stating how much each treat would cost.
Being allergic to everything under the sun, I very much appreciate this blog post! Some of these are my favorites and some I have never heard of!
Looks like a great list of healthy snacks <3
These all sound amazing!
I have Justin’s dark chocolate pb cups in my thrive cart right now!
Justin’s sweets are my favorite because of the healthy fats like peanuts and chocolate.
Super amazing alternatives btw also have been looking arbitrary your blog and it’s so cute! Will definitely follow… thank you so much for the opportunity ❤️?
Justins are sooo good!
I love my chocolate so it’s nice to learn about healthier alternatives. I have a sweet tooth so it’s a struggle of mine, thanks for blogging about better choices.
I would like to try the lolly pops to give to my Grand children when they visit.. You have a great variety of healthy substitutes for me to try. Thank you.
the smart sweets look yummy! love these alternative sweets…
Justin’s Dark Chocolate PB cups are my absolute favorite! Thanks for including the price breakdown – definitely helpful for this year’s trick-or-treaters!
thank you for writing this these are great options if we really need a sweet fix❤thx for the chance to win
Love chewy candy!
I love Olive You Whole!